Black Widow

The Marvel Cinematic Universe needs female-led superhero movies, but I was never sold on the idea of giving a solo adventure to Black Widow. For one, the character was already killed off in the last Avenger’s movie, and two, I never found Natasha Romanoff, the ex-Russian-assassin, all that interesting in the first place. Standing next to her Avengers team compatriots, Iron Man, Hulk, Thor, and Captain America, Black Widow was second tier and of secondary interest. But here we are, a movie with Black Widow at its center, and you know what? It’s surprisingly fun. But you know what else? It confirms that Black Widow really is a supporting character.

With Black Widow’s fate in the MCU, I knew this was going to have to be a prequel of some sort, and with the character’s background as a brainwashed assassin raised by an evil Russian organization, I figured Black Widow would be an origin story in the vain of the recent Jennifer Lawrence starring Red Sparrow, dour and unpleasant, where we follow Natasha as she rises through the ranks of a sadistic education while watched over by an uptight matronly figure, hair pulled back into a bun, carrying a ruler and curling her lips around an over-the-top Russian accent. “Da!” I imagined a prim Helen Mirren sneering.

But Black Widow isn’t that at all.

Thank goodness.

Rather, the movie is a spry and surprisingly funny globe-trotting thriller set between Captain America: Civil War and Avengers: Infinity War that surrounds Black Widow with a great cast playing supremely enjoyable new characters. Director Cate Shortland keeps the movie afloat with themes of family and interfamilial squabbles, and she puts a refreshing emphasis on Black Widow trying to help people rather than murdering her adversaries. But then the movie runs into the brick wall that is the MCU third act. But I’ll get into that later.

The movie begins strongly with a lengthy flashback sequence that friend and fellow movie critic Rubén Rosario succinctly described as Running on Empty with a dash of The Americans: sun dappled imagery and idyllic Americana enveloping a suddenly tense drama. The opening works so well it somehow isn’t undone by the ensuing credit sequence set to a somber, orchestral backed cover of…”Smells Like Teen Spirit”?! Yup, I’m not kidding. It’s super cringey on the one hand, but somehow it still works. I guess some songs are so good you can’t ruin them (although f*cking The Muppets from 2011 gave it their best shot).

I once described Scarlett Johansson as “fascinating and sympathetic even when playing a bit of a blank slate.” I wish I still felt the same way here. Johansson returns to play the titular Black Widow, but despite her talents, disappears in her own movie. The supporting characters are more entertaining and easily outshine her, especially her newly introduced sister, Yelena, played by radiant up-and-comer Florence Pugh, and her father, an alcoholic, Russian ex- (or really, never-) superhero called Red Guardian, played with rumpled charm by the ever-dependable David Harbour. In a weird way, the movie seems to realize that these characters are more interesting and almost serves as a tentative backdoor pilot to more adventures with these characters.

Things move along nicely: Introductions, some mystery, a bunch of action. The action is fine if nothing terribly special, but a car chase through the streets of Budapest benefits from the nice scenery of location shooting. In general, the copious chases and fisticuffs acquit themselves just fine, but too much chintzy CGI does them in a bit. Often, things that should have real weight, an SUV flung through the air, a motorcycle jumping over a car, zip across the screen, lighter than air and as fast as a character in a Benny Hill sketch.

After a bunch of action beats, the movie downshifts to let the characters interact with each other. These scenes are not only a necessary breather but provide the movie with its heart. The problem though is that just as these scenes start wrapping up and the movie gears up for third act finale fireworks, it just keeps gearing up and gearing up, trying to frantically set up a finale with a villain that has been too far in the background for the film’s run time.

And now, for that “typical MCU third act” I sniffed about earlier. I want to clarify that, in general, I like the MCU’s finales, which usually feature a hidden base, lots of explosions, and a host of cannon fodder bad guys for the heroes to spectacularly dispatch. Black Widow is no different, except it feels more perfunctory than ever and keeps the spectacular dispatching to a low simmer, as if Cate Shortland really didn’t give a shit about any of it. The setting is laughably stereotypical and revealed with a hushed awe as if we haven’t seen something like it a million times in the MCU before. Still, it could have been promising, these kinds of fanciful locations always grab my interest (I’m being vague on purpose, by the way. Spoilers, you know?) but not much is done with it visually. We barely glimpse it from the outside, and inside it’s just mostly generic, indistinct hallways and rooms without windows rife for blowing the f*ck up.

Eventually, we end up in a room with the main hero and the main villain. But instead of a tense stand-off, it plays more like a dull and endless conversation as Ray Winstone reveals his plans (with a dodgy Russian accent that can’t quite exorcise his inherent British-ness), only to be rebutted by Black Widow explaining her plan instead, back and forth they seem to plan and replan while the runtime keeps adding up. Finally, something happens, and while there are some neat moments, it all feels too little too late with a liberal pinch of (to stick with these overused platitudes) been there, done that.

But after the characters stand in the wreckage of yet another blow-‘em-up finale, the movie doubles down on its familial bonding and on Black Widow herself trying to be a better person instead of just the last person standing. What can I say? I’m a sucker for that stuff. So, while I don’t think that Black Widow ultimately proves the need for its existence, I’m glad it exists all the same.    

-Pavel Klein


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s